Thesis examination. The thesis examination itself is undertaken by at least two nominated expert reviewers with international standing in the relevant academic field(s). Students may be invited to suggest or comment on the suitability of possible examiners, but Estimated Reading Time: 4 mins The complete PhD (including the coursework and research components) normally takes 3 to 4 years of full-time research. During this time, each candidate writes a thesis, which is submitted for examination by three external examiners who are experts in the relevant field. The examiners will assess the thesis and recommend whether the PhD be awarded There are several eForms which fall under the Thesis Submission and Examinations banner, including the: Notification of Intent to Submit milestone, Thesis Submission milestone, Thesis Distribution and Examination eForm, and. Thesis Correction eForm. Together, these eForms allow staff and students to manage every stage of Thesis Submission and Examination through a centralised and streamlined
Day 2: Is your thesis big enough? Examination and the PhD – Pomodorobreak
This Pomodoro Break is designed to give you short, targeted information while you are having a coffee break. Each day this week we will explore topics related to the final document you submit for examination, your thesis. Where are you up to in your studies — do you have a definite submission date yet? How do you imagine that day of submission?
One of the big challenges of the PhD is that, ultimately, it must be examined, invoking many of the fears we have regarding examinations from past educational experiences. This is quite different from submitting a research article to a journal, where we might expect some formative feedback on how to revise and improve the paper before a final decision is made to accept it for publication. This high-stakes examination is as much about your identity as a scholar being allowed into the academy as it is about the quality of the research itself.
Maybe the job I hoped for is not out there waiting for me; maybe the brilliant career everyone expects me to live out may not be available; maybe my days will become empty without this big project to keep me connected into the University environment.
More on researcher identities in a future Pomodoro Break course. One anu phd thesis examination the mysteries surrounding PhD examination relates to the expected standard. The Australian Qualifications Framework AQF identifies this for us at Level 10 scroll down to p This can sound very general, though, and relating these broad skills, knowledge and application to the thesis itself can help conceptualise what you are aiming for.
But having a sense of what you are aiming for is useful: this blog by Claire Aitchison is anu phd thesis examination for moving into an evaluative mindset regarding your own work.
Use the comments function below to explain why you think these are the most important. Is it the person or the thesis that is being examined? ACTIVITY: If you were examining a PhD thesis, what would you be looking for? What makes a research project worth a PhD? What do you regard as the most important elements? Imagine you had to assign points for the main criteria listed by ANU — what weighting would you give to each of these 4 criteria?
Are there other criteria you would like to add to this list? Use the comments function to tell us what you anu phd thesis examination. If I had to choose the top 3 of all 12 of doctorates synergy elements, then I would choose: 1.
Contribution to knowledge 2. Conceptual framework 3. Appropriate methodology. I think those three elements that characterise and differentiate a scientific PhD work from other typical investigation work.
Thank you for being the first person to add a comment, Depi! No worries, Cally! I agree with Rosie — all four criteria are important in assessing a PhD thesis. However, I am curious how the examiner would examine the criteria of independent research if the research is part of a big project. For example, a PhD student is part of the research team working on a big topic in the same area? Good point, anu phd thesis examination, Depi. Not sure if that helps, anu phd thesis examination, but we can talk more about this.
Stated gap in knowledge 3. Explicit research questions 4. Conceptual framework. Activity 2 — Interpreting the Assessment Criteria If I were marking a PhD in Humanities!
In terms of the assessment criteria provided, I think the personal criteria is about my ability to show that I am able to learn, and that I have developed as a researcher through the PhD process. Comparatively, the marks for work itself seem to be moreso about conduct, and the structure and communication of information.
They seem to ask the writer to consider and present research practices as cohesive professional tools the academic uses. The only thing I pause at is 1. Hi Rosie — thanks for being an early starter �� Nice to see how you are lining up the parts of the thesis to make sure it all comes together in the final document. However, the rather vague criteria are part of why it can feel rather anu phd thesis examination at times. Agree completely about the need to engage the examiner — it would be a long slog for someone to read a long, dry, anu phd thesis examination, uninteresting thesis.
Interested in your thoughts. Activity 1 Components Yes all the components seem important however these three stand out for me. Anu phd thesis examination to knowledge — to me this is the essence of the PhD and to do this successfully you will cover off many of the other points including these two below, anu phd thesis examination.
Research questions answered — we have to have focused research questions and answer them, anu phd thesis examination. Appropriate methodology — however to make the contribution and answer the questions we need to investigate the issue in a way that is suitable for the topic and context.
Activity 2 Assessment Criteria All these aspects seem important to me but if I have to weight them I would guess the following with number 1 having highest because as commented above to me this is key to the PhD. Constructive alignment Biggs was right! The gap 2research questions 3 and framework 4 would probably be my top contenders, too, with the rest falling into line behind those.
emphasis on clarity of the final output as quite a linear recount, rather than any explicit space to acknowledge the roundabout journey we might take in our projects. There is discussion about how much of that ought to appear in the thesis itself — overcoming problems in the research can be an important aspect of the contribution to knowledge, anu phd thesis examination. The conventions of the thesis genre vary between disciplines, and examiners are likely to expectations of what this looks like at doctoral level.
Very useful questions for us to ponder…. A thoughtful reply, thanks Cally. Is that true? Do others have opinions about how they see themselves negotiating this part of the process? Contribution to knowledge has always been a core feature of what a PhD means to me. Doing research that contributes seems a fundamental part of the PhD. Cogent argument throughout shows thought and understanding of the material, and an ability to communicate this effectively.
Answering the research questions also seems a fundamental part of the PhD, as stating what was learned shows that the research was thought through, can be communicated clearly to others, anu phd thesis examination, and can be used in the field.
Do you want to tell us more about this feeling that carrying out independent research and making a substantial contribution to knowledge is slightly more important than the other criteria? I am 4th year of a part time PhD anu phd thesis examination psychology, anu phd thesis examination.
Like many others, COVID has derailed my plans for this year personally and professionally. To me, at the moment, the key requirements for a thesis are: a cogent argument; originality; and a contribution to the field.
But if I was examining one, I would be looking for a thesis that is easy to read, that takes the reader systematically through the research and arguments.
That is, it should be easy to mark. Examiners are busy people, theses are long, and the easier it is to read, the easier it is to mark. Activity 1: I think mine would be original contribution, cogent argument and conceptual conclusions… and if I could choose a fourth probably conceptual framework and I imagine methodology come within that conceptual framework.
But oh so hard to choose! All are so important. Your comments show us how these decisions are not as straight forward as they appear at first. My main reason for presenting these anu phd thesis examination is so that they are sitting alongside you as you work towards preparing your final document for submission.
In examining humanities or social science thesis I do not look for perfection in spelling and grammar, though many do. I look for coherent arguments which means sound reasoning.
No romance and poetics, they are a waste of time when universities are meant to serve the community. Broad awareness of the cultural context of the topic. This is one area in which many researchers fail, even the best. I had a twitter discussion with a man who supported an article out of the Fenner School which argued that anu phd thesis examination rice in the MRDB was the best crop when water is available.
As we know, the growing of rice is one of the major causes of water shortages in the lower parts of the MRDB. Good points, Aileen and common sense always seems useful! I think of the thesis as demonstrating a kind of T-shaped knowledge — a broad understanding of the field itself and what is relevant to the project, with a deep dive into a very specific topic in that field.
My take away from this is anu phd thesis examination a really neat, tidy document makes examiners feel confident that the work has been careful, anu phd thesis examination, thorough and scholarly in other ways too.
Thanks Cally, T shaped knowledge is a useful image to keep in mind. As is the point on proof reading, anu phd thesis examination. Poor presentation does annoy me, believe me, anu phd thesis examination.
But I try to not let it anu phd thesis examination my perspective of what I consider more important elements of a thesis, anu phd thesis examination. Your email address will not be published. Skip to content. ACTIVITY: Components of doctorateness: The sum is greater than the parts. Conceptual framework 5.
Explicit research design 6. Appropriate methodology 7. Full engagement with theory Cogent argument throughout Research questions answered Conceptual conclusions What is really being examined?
WHEN MY WIFE SUBMIT THESIS IN ANU
, time: 6:22Day 1: Is your thesis good enough? Examination and the PhD – Pomodorobreak
Science (CoS) guidelines on HDR examinations aim to ensure high quality, independent and timely examination of HDR theses. This document sets out the conditions for examinations and appointment of examiners and should be read in conjunction with the Research Awards Rule, and the HDR policies and procedures relating to examinations Anu Phd Thesis Examination get academic help for Anu Phd Thesis Examination your assignment from an expert writer. Whether time is an issue or you have other obligations to take care of, this can be the solution to turn to when wondering who can do my assignment for me at a price I can afford There are several eForms which fall under the Thesis Submission and Examinations banner, including the: Notification of Intent to Submit milestone, Thesis Submission milestone, Thesis Distribution and Examination eForm, and. Thesis Correction eForm. Together, these eForms allow staff and students to manage every stage of Thesis Submission and Examination through a centralised and streamlined
No comments:
Post a Comment